Senators want temporary halt of oil flow through pipelines

FILE - This Feb. 11, 2014, aerial file photo shows a view of the Mackinac Bridge, which spans a 5-mile-wide freshwater channel called the Straits of Mackinac that separates Michigan's upper and lower peninsulas. Sen. Gary Peters of Michigan said Friday, April 13, 2018, that the flow of crude oil through twin pipelines through the Straits should be suspended until authorities determine how severely they were damaged by what may have been a ship anchor strike. The Coast Guard is delaying action because of a heavy storm expected this weekend. (Keith King/Traverse City Record-Eagle via AP, Pool, File)

TRAVERSE CITY, Mich. — Michigan's two senators called Friday for temporarily shutting down twin oil pipelines in a sensitive Great Lakes waterway that may have been damaged by a ship anchor strike, which also is suspected in the leak of coolant fluid from nearby electric cables.

With an underwater inspection planned for early next week, Democratic Sens. Gary Peters and Debbie Stabenow said oil should not continue flowing through Enbridge Inc.'s Line 5 in the Straits of Mackinac until it's certain the pipes are in good shape. A wintry storm bearing down on the area made the situation more perilous, Peters said.

"Upcoming blizzard conditions and high winds pose a threat to the already-damaged pipeline and —even worse — would render on-site cleanup equipment ineffective in the event of an oil spill," he said. "We simply cannot afford that kind of risk to Michigan's most precious natural resource."

Enbridge spokesman Ryan Duffy said the Canadian company was monitoring the situation and "should the weather deteriorate to a point where we are concerned about the ability for our personnel to respond to an incident, we will temporarily shut down."

Line 5 carries about 23 million gallons (87 million liters) of crude oil and liquefied natural gas daily between Superior, Wisconsin, and Sarnia, Ontario. The segment that crosses the 5-mile-wide (8-kilometer-wide) straits linking Lakes Huron and Michigan is divided into two side-by-side pipes that were laid on the lake bottom in 1953.

Enbridge used mechanical tools to inspect their interior after two electric cables in the vicinity leaked 600 gallons (2,270 liters) of insulation fluid containing mineral oil and benzene earlier this month. One pipe had two small dents and the other had one, the company said, describing them as minor and insisting the integrity of the lines weren't compromised.

The Coast Guard says it's investigating the cause of the electric cable leak and that "vessel activity" may have been a factor. But it has declined to confirm speculation by Gov. Rick Snyder and other elected officials that a dropped anchor was the culprit. The straits area is used frequently by cargo ships and recreational boats.

Peters, who questioned Coast Guard officers about the investigation during a Commerce Committee hearing Thursday in Washington, D.C., said Friday he was told in a separate briefing that a visual inspection was needed to fully assess the extent of the oil pipeline damage.

Enbridge plans to deploy a remote underwater vehicle to examine the pipes' exterior Monday, Duffy said.

The American Transmission Company, owner of the ruined power cables, also plans a separate remote probe of the ruined electric cables next week.

Snyder pressed Enbridge on Wednesday to expedite studies of ways to prevent damage to Line 5 from an anchor, including replacing the pipes with others in a tunnel beneath the lake bed.

Asked Friday for a response to the senators' call for a Line 5 shutdown, Snyder spokeswoman Anna Heaton said Lt. Gov. Brian Calley visited the site earlier this week and met with Coast Guard officials.

"They reported no immediate threat from Line 5," Heaton said. "If we receive any information that indicates an immediate health or safety threat from this source of heat for the Upper Peninsula during the approaching winter storm, we will act accordingly."

The Coast Guard and other agencies have been monitoring the straits by boat and air but have reported no sheen or other evidence of pollution. Those operations were suspended for the weekend because of the expected storm.


Follow John Flesher on Twitter at

Must Read

China tries to reassure foreign companies over...

Mar 11, 2017

China's industry minister has defended a manufacturing development plan and rejected complaints...

Computer beats Chinese champion in ancient board...

May 23, 2017

A computer that plays go has defeated China's top player of the ancient board came and the Chinese...

AP Explains: Why China is stepping up against...

Jun 2, 2017

AP Explains: China is stepping forward to expand its renewable energy industry as President Donald...

Liu Xiaobo supporters mark his death amid...

Jul 19, 2017

Supporters of Liu Xiaobo are gathering worldwide to mark the traditional Chinese observance of the...

Stock markets slide as tech earnings underwhelm

Jul 28, 2017

Asian, European shares slide as concerns spread over Wall Street's tech sell-off

About Us

RedShiftDaily was started out of fascination with mankind discoveries through peering out into the cosmos. Our team of enthusiasts are going to deliver only the best and latest progress in space technology and discovery so you too can share in the excitement.

Contact us: sales[at]